By Scott Rainey
When teaching middle school students, it is imperative to remember that, while students may be showing signs of maturity and growth, they are still children. And as children, they are still forming their belief systems and attitudes. As one would expect, the beliefs and attitudes of students are formed primarily in the home. Usually, the attitudes expressed by our students are consistent with the kind of values we would expect in a society that values freedom and fairness.
Unfortunately, though, there are times when students express views that do not reflect, as Abraham Lincoln termed it, our “better angels.” It is during these times that a teacher must tread carefully, for a misdirected word said in anger, even righteous anger, could easily demolish the relationship between the teacher and the student. When middle school students say things that are provocative, it behooves a teacher to remember that they are works in progress, and that, as the proverb states, a kind word can not only turn away wrath, but change a mind.
The Indian Removal Act is one of the most challenging chapters of American history to teach. As a self-proclaimed patriot who truly loves this country, I find these parts of the American story the most compelling, because they demonstrate that as a country, we remain a work in progress.
The Indian Removal Act is one of the most challenging chapters of American history to teach. As a self-proclaimed patriot who truly loves this country, I find these parts of the American story the most compelling, because they demonstrate that as a country, we remain a work in progress.
“We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union….” With those four little words in the Preamble to the Constitution, the founders set an incredibly high bar for us. When those words were written in Philadelphia in 1787, huge swaths of people living in the boundaries of the nascent United States did not enjoy the same freedoms heralded by the group of wealthy, well-connected white men who put those ideas down on parchment. It is likely they, even given their extraordinary intellect, could not conceive of the doors those four words — a more perfect union — would open.
“We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union…” With those four little words in the Preamble to the Constitution, the founders set an incredibly high bar for us.
Recently, I found myself teaching about a particularly challenging chapter of the American story. My class watched a very well-made film prepared by the National Park Service that dramatized the Indian Removal Act through the tragedy of the Cherokee Trail of Tears. The film followed a tribal elder and his granddaughter through the various stages of injustice visited upon the Cherokee people, from the imposition of the government of the state of Georgia upon their lands (a long and sordid story of broken promises and outright land grabs to benefit white settlers) to the administration of Andrew Jackson, which wholly ignored the decision of the Supreme Court that the Cherokee could not be removed from their land. “(Chief Justice of the Supreme Court) Marshall has made his decision, now let him try to enforce it,” Jackson reportedly said after the Supreme Court found his administration’s actions to be in violation of the rights of the Cherokee people (Worcester vs. Georgia, 1832).
The Encyclopedia Britannica reports that up to 100,000 people were uprooted by the United States government (members of the so-called “civilized tribes” — Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Seminole and Creek) and forced to walk hundreds of miles overland to what was termed the “Indian Territory” in modern-day Oklahoma. The same source notes that it is estimated that approximately 15,000 of those participants in this forced migration died along the way.
Now, a hallmark of bright middle school students is the verbal grenade — a query or statement injected into a discussion designed to shake the sensibilities of all present. These figurative explosives aren’t always meant maliciously; in fact, in my experience, many are lobbed either in ignorance or in a genuine desire to raise questions. This day, one very bright young man launched a particularly challenging verbal explosive. He asked, “How is this different from any other time in history? I mean, people have been taking land from other people since the beginning of time.”
A hallmark of bright middle school students is the verbal grenade, a query or statement injected into a discussion designed to shake the sensibilities of all present.
Such a statement could easily be construed as trying to challenge the general narrative of American history, at least as taught in recent years and informed by teachers like the late Dr. Howard Zinn. Dr. Zinn and others helped to usher in a more critical analysis of American history, which in many cases had been taught more as a mythology of American Exceptionalism than as a telling of the true facts.
As a person who considers himself an unapologetic patriot, I believe it is essential to teach students the unvarnished truth of America, “warts and all,” as it were. I believe that teaching children fairy tales about our nation’s founding only does them a disservice and perpetuates ideas and mindsets that keep us mired in immobility as a society. I do believe that America is exceptional. It is exceptional not because of the jingoistic half-truths and outright lies usually taught unknowingly by well-meaning but misinformed teachers. It is exceptional because of the potential we have, because of the incredibly lofty goals set by a group of admittedly privileged white men over two centuries ago. And it was the words of those visionaries that I used in answer to my student’s question.
My response came directly from the heart of all I believe about what America was, is and could be if we only gave ourselves the chance. “What’s different,” I told him, “is that we live under a higher standard that says, in part: ‘We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.’ That’s what separates us from every other society and group of people since the beginning of time. We’re trying to live up to a higher standard.”
“What’s different,” I told him, “is that we live under a higher standard.”
My student grew quiet for a moment, then asked, “Okay, fine, but when did this (the Indian Removal Act) take place again?”
“Well,” I told him, “the legislation was passed in 1830, and it carried on for about 11 years.”
“All right, so when did they say the other thing?”
“About ‘life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness’”?
“Yeah.”
“Well, that’s from the Declaration of Independence — so almost 55 years earlier.”
He looked at me in stunned silence, then off into the distance for a few seconds, gathering his thoughts.
He finally looked back at me, a small smile gracing his face. “Okay. That makes sense, then.”
I hope Dr. Zinn would be proud.
Scott Rainey is a National Board-certified teacher who teaches 8th grade US history at Jemtegaard Middle School in Washougal, WA, where he has been on the staff since 1998. He received the Veterans of Foreign Wars Department of Washington’s Citizenship Education Middle School Teacher of the Year award for 2021-2022. He is married to his best friend Katrina, and is the father of three adopted daughters. He loves the Beatles, 80’s alternative rock, Shakespeare, geocaching and traveling.

Love this post? See “The Lie of the ‘Kumbaya’ Moment,” and “Teaching During Covid: Cherish the Coconuts,” also by Scott Rainey.


Deja un comentario