Why the nativity scene still resonates so powerfully

By Nancy Turner

In 1223, Saint Francis of Assisi created a nativity scene to help children understand the true meaning of Christmas. He wanted to remind the world that the season was about more than giving and receiving gifts, but rather about celebrating the birth of a special baby.

Nancy Turner

His depiction of the baby Jesus, Mary, and Joseph was set up in a cave in Greccio, Italy, using live people and real animals. He did this to show the world that the spirit of Christmas was not to be materialized, but treasured.

In the 1500s, high-class people began displaying nativity scenes in their homes. Artists created versions made of various materials such as wood, wax, and fine fabrics. Churches also began displaying creche scenes. Nowadays the sight of the nativity in Christian churches evokes the miracle of Jesus’ humble birth.

Throughout my childhood, I was the one who set up the family nativity set in mid-December. I acquired my first set as an adult in 1977, when my son was born in December. For the next 45 years, I’ve picked sets up at estate sales, second-hand stores, and Mexican and Guatemalan markets.

The most expensive one is a large glass snow globe with a music box at the bottom that plinks out “Silent Night.” That was years ago. I splurged and spent $39.

I’ve collected nativities made of all sorts of material. Wood, glass, china, plastic, metal, straw, cloth, you name it. One is a traveling set made of metal with figures that collapse flat into a folded envelope of tin.

I’ve collected nativities made of all sorts of material. Wood, glass, china, plastic, metal, straw, cloth, you name it. One is a traveling set made of metal with figures that collapse flat into a folded envelope of tin. The smallest is carved of stone and measures about an inch across.

At first glance several look identical until you notice the fabric of the figures’ clothing. In Guatemala, weavers make cloth particular to their village. One can tell where a person lives by their dress. Hence, my sets from Guatemala might look alike, but each one is from a different village.

African nativity set

One of the most unique ones is from a junk store in a small town just north of Corvallis. The figures stand about three inches and are African. A giraffe, zebra, and lion surround the mud hut.

Five years ago as I packed my belongings to move from a large house into a small apartment, I counted over 100 sets.

Good grief.

My movers were undocumented refugees from El Salvador and belonged to a local Christian church. When I asked how many families were in their congregation, the men shrugged their shoulders, but their wives knew. I quickly was able to unload 30 sets.

They were delighted, and I was happy, too.

Why my fetish for creches? I rationalize that I was attracted to their artistic and ethnic qualities. They are small and easy to store. The largest one was handmade of clay in Chichicastenango, Guatemala. The camels accompanying the wise men stand about 14 inches.

Still, people collect baseball cards or dolls or miniature cars, but nativity sets?

It wasn’t until I studied Jungian psychology that I began to understand my fascination with these figures.

As the one in my family who carefully assembled the family set every Christmas, I learned to look at the nativity set not only as a way of honoring the birth of Jesus, but as much more.

Guatemalan nativity set figures

I look at the nativity as symbolic of the self, of representing a whole human, the unconscious psyche of a person. With this point of view, Joseph represents the masculine aspects of our selves. Mary, our feminine side. The baby Jesus represents our vulnerable selves, our great potential for new growth.

I was told the names of the three wise men bearing gifts for the baby were Insight, Intuition and Inspiration. I have no idea if that’s true, but I like it. We all have an internal shepherd that keeps us in line, making sure we don’t get lost. The animals signify our instinctual nature. The angel Gabriel sheds light on our spirituality.

I was told the names of the three wise men bearing gifts for the baby were Insight, Intuition and Inspiration. I have no idea if that’s true, but I like it. We all have an internal shepherd that keeps us in line, making sure we don’t get lost.

Why was Jesus not born in a palace, or at least a Hilton Hotel? Well, what could be more modest than a stable? We all have humble beginnings. I don’t mean financially, I mean psychologically. In Jungian psychology and dream analysis, the home or house is a metaphor of the self. From this unusual perspective, a stable makes sense.

There is something universally appealing about seeing a mother and father hovering over their newborn baby.

Fourteen years ago, my daughter, as a single woman addicted to meth, had a baby in December. Elena knew she was unable to raise a child. As she put it, “I can barely take care of myself.” She placed her baby for adoption with a lesbian couple in Seattle. Since the baby had been exposed to meth, we figured two mothers would be better than one. As a gift to the happy couple, I prepared a nativity set for them. I retired Joseph and inserted a second Mary figure. Two Marys knelt by the manger cradling a sleeping baby.

Fourteen years ago, my daughter, as a single woman addicted to meth, had a baby in December. Elena knew she was unable to raise a child.

There are many ways to build a family.

As I write, I’m listening to “Away in a Manger” and marvel at how the story of a birth that happened centuries ago still resonates in our hearts. Even people who are not particularly Christian display a nativity set at Christmas.

I’m with Saint Francis of Assisi. When we see a replication of this special family, we recall the true meaning of Christmas.

May we have peace on earth and goodwill to all.


Nancy Turner moved from Portland to The Dalles three years ago. She is a retired psychotherapist and real estate investor, and parent of three grown children. She lives in a Victorian-style house with her dog and three cats. To share her love of the outdoors, she founded Broads and Dogs (the BADs), a hiking group in the Gorge for women, their dogs, and well-behaved men. Contact her at Nancyturner100@gmail.com. This essay originally appeared in CCCNews.

All photos courtesy of Nancy Turner.

Responses

  1.  Avatar

    Lovely. Your story is a delightful reminder of how so many people across time and place are drawn to the nativity. Our family has set up our nativity set for the last 40 years. It has only lasted through four children and now 14 grandchildren because the pieces, though realistic looking people and animals, are made of plastic. It is always at the children’s level so they can handle and rearrange the setting. My children added a cat figure many years ago to represent a character from the book The Christmas Cat. The cat was a lowly outcast in a difficult and sad life. The story ends with the cat coming to recognize that even the lowliest outcasts were invited to the side of the Christ child. Peace and goodwill to all.

  2. JP Avatar

    I remember growing up with a table nativity scene that my parents got out every Christmas when I was young. It had all the expected figures (people, stable, animals, etc., plus real hay) and they let me set it up. I didn’t really understand the story or symbolism, but I knew it represented something important and I think I felt important for being given the task to set it up. Hadn’t thought about that in a long time but your post brought the memories back. Thanks for sharing.

Leave a Reply